By John Corrado
Paper Tiger finds writer-director James Gray returning to the gritty New York City crime movies of earlier in his career, while also crafting a surprising follow-up to his 2022 autobiographical drama Armageddon Time.
While in a different key and register than Armageddon Time, Paper Tiger nonetheless feels of a piece with it, both in showing a faded New York of the past, and in taking inspiration from Gray’s own upbringing and the lives of his parents.
The result is a film that effortlessly weaves together elements of mob movie, crime drama, and family melodrama to quietly gripping effect, with Gray both building suspense and offering deeper notes of mournful pathos running beneath the surface.
We follow Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller), a somewhat meek engineer in Queen’s, New York who is trying to support his wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and their two teenaged sons, Scott (Gavin Goudey) and Ben (Roman Engel). The year is 1986, and Irwin’s family lives a modest life, contrasted by his brother Gary (Adam Driver). Gary is a former NYPD officer turned mob-adjacent wheeler and dealer who has financially done well for himself, and drives a nice car that Irwin’s boys envy.
One night, Gary comes to Irwin with a business proposition that would see them overseeing the cleanup of the highly polluted Gowanus Canal, dragging him into a precarious business deal involving the highly dangerous Russian mafia. Yes, Paper Tiger delivers some of the pulpy thrills of a mob movie set during the Red Scare, and it works quite effectively as a simmering crime movie.
But it’s also a story about the impact that individual choices have upon a family. There is a bleakness to the film that feels devastating when we look back on everything that transpires. Even the violence when it comes happens in the quietest of ways. Gray isn’t exploiting or glamorizing the violence, but rather showing the tragedy of it, and the culminating consequences of the individual choices that lead up to it.
The film is carried by Teller, Johansson, and Driver, delivering a trio of performances that all compliment each other very well. Teller is quite convincing playing a nerdy family man getting in over his head, a role that feels distinct from how he was being cast earlier in his career. Driver exudes coolness and charm, the type of figure who has convinced himself of his own infallibility and success, and is magnetic enough to convince others to follow him as well.
Johansson is able to go big, including a 1980s hairdo, thick New York accent, and a few fiery moments when she confronts her husband. But her character is undergirded by a sadness that she has to keep buried inside. Her performance has already been unfairly dismissed by some as being overly melodramatic, but it’s heartbreaking work. Johansson is playing a wife and mother tasked with holding her family together while slowly realizing that she is basically on her own, despite having a husband and kids to support her, and the tragedy of her character comes through in the end.
If Teller and Johansson’s characters feel somewhat familiar, it’s because Gray based them on his own parents, who were similarly portrayed by Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway in Armageddon Time (Strong and Hathaway were even reportedly set to reprise these roles, before dropping out and being replaced by Teller and Johansson instead).
As much as Paper Tiger is about the grownups, we are also seeing things from the perspective of the two boys, even if the childhood vantage point is not as front and centre as it was in Armageddon Time. If Teller, Driver, and Johansson are getting the bulk of the praise, young actors Goudey and Engel also deserve special mention as well, including one chillingly tense scene involving the two boys.
Gray makes films that feel like memories, and Paper Tiger is no different, with an evocative sense of time and place. It’s beautifully shot on 35mm film by cinematographer Joaquin Baca-Asay, capturing the grittiness of 1980s New York, with the period authentic production design helping transport us back to the era. While the Trump family is not directly featured or referenced here (unlike in Armageddon Time), their influence obviously loomed large over Queen’s, New York at the time.
There is an unsettling tension running throughout Paper Tiger that Gray is able to maintain through to the haunting final moments, delivering an emotional impact that we don’t even quite realize until it’s over and the credits start rolling. A powerful crime drama, and an even more powerful family story.
