By John Corrado
Polish filmmaker Paweł Pawlikowski’s Fatherland is the third film in a trilogy of sorts following 2013’s Ida and 2018’s exceptional Cold War, offering a triptych of portraits exploring post-WWII Europe.
This film is set in 1949, and follows the writer Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler) and his daughter Erika (Sandra Hüller) on a road trip across Germany following World War II. Erika travels with him to receive the Goethe Prize in Frankfurt, acting as his translator.
Thomas receives an invitation to receive a second prize in Weimar, leading to fears that they will face persecution when they return to the United States if they visit the Soviet-backed communist regime in East Germany.
Pawlikowski, who was awarded the Best Director prize at Cannes for Fatherland (an award he shared with Javier Ambrossi and Javier Calvo for La Bola Negra in a tie), uses this deceptively simple narrative backdrop to craft an evocative and intellectually stimulating portrait of Germany at a literal crossroads after the war.
We see the juxtaposition of Thomas and Erika driving through streets with bombed out buildings, before being feted at high society gatherings by rich folks who wish to move on from the horrors of the Nazi era and rebuild their cultural institutions as if nothing happened. On the other side, Pawlikowski brilliantly allows for moments to creep in showing the progressive idealism of communism in East Berlin as its own sort of hell on earth, beneath the facade of pomp and circumstance they put on for their guests.
Like Cold War and Ida, Pawlikowski’s Fatherland unfolds through a series of long takes shot in black-and-white by cinematographer Łukasz Żal, and framed within a square Academy aspect ratio. The stark compositions of these frames, with characters in the foreground and movement happening in the background, are frequently quite striking. Żal’s cinematography also highlights the magnificent production design, recreating Germany at this moment in time.
Pawlikowski is not only exploring the physical toll of the death and destruction of World War II across Europe, but also the emotional voids left by the war. This is further explored in the dramatic push and pull between Thomas, whom Zischler credibly portrays as a brilliant but aloof intellectual, and Erika, with Hüller’s performance serving as the film’s emotional centre.
The film is short at just 82 minutes (even shorter if you remove the lengthy closing credits), but every extended scene here serves a purpose. There is no filler in Pawlikowski’s films. But, through Ida, Cold War and now Fatherland, he has crafted a series of films that, each in their own way, manage to burrow under our skin and leave an impact.
Throughout Fatherland, Pawlikowski beautifully lays the groundwork for the haunting final moments, mirroring the earlier films in this trilogy in a way that deepens the emotional impact.
